Years ago I remember asking someone the hypothetical question, "What if Jesus didn't rise from the dead?" He answered, "Well, at least you would have led a good life."
That's not what Paul argued: "If only for this life we have hope in Christ, we are to be pitied more than all men" (1 Cor. 15:19). The historical reality of the resurrection is central to the Christian faith. No resurrection, no salvation.
This is going to be the topic of conversation in my Shepherding Group on Sunday morning at MVBC as we continue to think about evangelism with the Matthias Media presentation called 2 Ways 2 Live. What does the resurrection mean for we approach God in worship? What does it mean for how we approach daily life--time, material goods, friendships.
In preparation for this session, I was helped by reviewing an excellent chapter on the resurrection by apologist/philosopher William Lane Craig. He wrote the essay "Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?" in Jesus Under Fire (Zondervan, 1995).
In the following excerpt, Craig explains one reason why it makes historical sense to believe Jesus rose from the dead:
Whatever they may think of the historical resurrection, even the most skeptical scholars admit that at least the belief that Jesus rose from the dead lay at the very heart of the earliest Christian faith. In fact, the earliest believers pinned nearly everything on it. The resurrection was the sine qua non for their belief in Jesus as Messiah and in his death as the basis for forgiveness of sins.
It is difficult to exaggerate what a devastating effect the crucifixion must have had on the disciples. They had no conception of a dying, much less a rising, Messiah, for the Messiah would reign forever (cf. John 12:34). Without prior belief in the resurrection, belief in Jesus as Messiah would have been impossible in light of his death. The resurrection turned catastrophe into victory. Because God raised Jesus from the dead, he could be proclaimed as Messiah after all (Acts 2:32, 36). Similarly for the significance of the cross—it was his resurrection that enabled Jesus’ shameful death to be interpreted in salvific terms. Without it, Jesus’ death would have meant only humiliation and accursedness by God; but in view of the resurrection it could be seen to be the event by which forgiveness of sins was obtained. Without the resurrection, the Christian Way could never have come into being. Even if the disciples had continued to remember Jesus as their beloved teacher, they could not have believed in him as Messiah, much less deity.