It was simple question, "How should I dress when I visit?" Some friends and I were sitting down at a restaurant, enjoying a meal and discussing an edifying Christian book. Our waitress noticed the title of the book, and she was curious enough to ask about it. After a short conversation, we discovered she was new to the area. So I invited her to church. She seemed eager to come.
That's when she asked, "How should I dress?" She wanted to know if we were formal or informal, uptight or casual. She didn't want to show up in a suit-kind-of-church wearing cutoffs and flip-flops. And she didn't want to show up in a jeans-kind-of-church decked out in an Easter dress. It's a good question.
So I fumbled out an answer, "Come how you'd like." I wanted her to know that we weren't the kind of church that cared about what people wear.
But we do. Every church does. Whether we are formal or informal, you can look around and get a sense of what expectations we have, collectively, when it comes to attire. But we must be careful not to confuse how we dress with how we worship.
This is why I appreciate David Peterson's book, Engaging with God: A Biblical Theology of Worship. For the most part, this book is one long Bible study looking at the idea of worship through the Old and New Testaments. Just here and there does he pop up to reflect upon how his study might influence our thoughts on public services today. Notice what he says about whether a church should be formal or informal:
Formality and informality are not theological categories. Yet sometimes people imply that formality in church services is somehow more conducive to acceptable worship than informality. Others argue that informality is preferable because it allows for greater expression of biblical teaching about the congregation as the body of Christ. Formality may be the expression of a very narrow and inadequate view of worship and informality may be an excuse for lack of preparation or any serious attempt to engage collectively with God. Apart from the size of the gathering, the question of formality and informality will often be decided in practical terms by the personalities of those in charge and by the particular traditions of the group in question.
At MVBC, our Sunday morning services are fairly formal. Though there will be just a handful of men in jackets and ties, much of the service will lead you to conclude we are on the formal end of the spectrum--everything from the decor, to the carefully ordered services, to my preaching (almost always in a jacket and sometimes with a tie), to the willingness to sing older hymns that are often reflective in tone.
At the end of the day, the most important question is not how formal the service is but how Christ-centered it is. Are we honoring the Savior in what we sing, in how we sing, in how we pray and preach and respond to the Word? Let our attention be focused on the Savior first and foremost, with sincere hearts, and the Lord will be glorified.